It's one of the most common questions new dog owners ask: should my dog wear a collar or a harness? The short answer is — both, for different jobs. Here's how to use each one safely.
What a Collar Is Good For
A collar is your dog's everyday ID carrier. It holds their name tag and council registration, it's always on, and it's quick to grab in a hurry. For a calm dog who doesn't pull, a collar is perfectly fine for short, relaxed walks too. What it isn't great for is controlling a puller — all that force lands on the throat.
What a Harness Is Good For
A harness spreads lead pressure across the chest and shoulders instead of the neck. That makes it safer and more comfortable, especially for dogs who pull, flat-faced breeds, small dogs with delicate windpipes, and puppies whose necks are still developing. A no-pull harness also gives you far more control without hurting your dog.
The Verdict: Use Both
The setup most trainers recommend: a collar with ID tags worn at all times, plus a harness clipped on for walks. You get the safety and control of a harness, and your dog still carries ID if they ever slip away.
Dogs That Should Always Walk in a Harness
- Pugs, French Bulldogs and other flat-faced breeds
- Toy and small breeds (Chihuahuas, Pomeranians, Dachshunds)
- Puppies still in training
- Any committed puller or escape artist
Our Picks for Both Jobs
Reflective No-Pull Dog Harness — from $24.99
For walks: takes pressure off the throat, redirects pulling, and keeps your dog visible in low light. Sizes XS–2XL.
Patterned Dog Collar & Lead Set — from $14.80
For everyday ID: an adjustable, comfortable collar in a range of patterns and sizes — with a matching lead included.
Harness vs Collar FAQs
Can my dog wear a collar and a harness at the same time?
Absolutely — that's the ideal setup. Collar for ID, harness for the lead.
Is a collar cruel?
Not at all for ID and gentle use. It only becomes a problem when a strong dog pulls hard against it on every walk — that's where a harness wins.
Which is better for a puppy?
A lightweight collar for ID, plus a no-pull harness for walks while they learn the ropes.
Shop Walking Gear at OzPetCo
Find the right fit across our harnesses and collars — fast Australian delivery, free shipping over $99.
